The tournament was first officially contested in 1923 as "The Springhaven Cup Invitational" although history and documentation date the "Springhaven Cup" back to 1902.
In 1923, Springhaven Club head pro, Andy Campbell, along with tournament committee founders Jack Sproul and M.H. Paul, officially began to construct "The Springhaven Cup Invitational". The tournament was designed to elicit the play of the nations elite golfers. The format was a 3-day event beginning with an 18 hole qualifier, followed by multiple 16-player match-play brackets.
On Thursday September 6th, 1923, over 250 contestants from all over the country descended upon Springhaven for the inaugural Springhaven Cup Invitational. The first competition was won by Springhaven Club superstar William "Bud" McIntire. McIntire qualified for match play with a score of 80 (1 below the cut of 81) followed by the match play victories below:
Opening Round - Defeated Marcus Greer 3&1 (1921 Quebec Amateur Champion and Philadelphia Amateur Runner-Up)
Quarterfinals - Defeated Joe Coble 1up through 20 holes (1924 US Amateur Public Links Champ, 1927 PGA Section Champion)
Semifinals - Defeated J. Wood Platt 1 up (USGA Sr. Amateur Champion, Pennsylvania Amateur Champion, 7x Philadelphia Amateur Champion, 7x Silver Cross Champion, 4x Patterson Cup Champion)
Finals - Defeated Charley Doelp (Kendrick Cup Champion)
In 1941, at the request of the membership, the tournament committee made the event a more inclusive invitation & member based event. They also moved the competition for the "Champions Cup" to a 36 hole Individual Medal Play for the first time. Along with the competition for the Cup, there were 4 other member and guest based events that took place over the weekend of September 28, 1941. The eventual champion was J. Wood Platt, who bested Billy Hyndman in a playoff after firing a course record 65 in the afternoon round.
The tournament continued in its original individual format until 1950 where tournament chairman, J Herbert "Herb" Glenn, changed the event to a two man team event. This change was strongly urged by the Springhaven membership. The first pairing to take home the championship were Bob Albertus and Leo Heller, who defeated Allan Sussel and Ira Gruber in the final match.From 1950-1954 the event was competed as a better-ball of partners match play tournament with 18 holes of qualifying, followed by multiple 16 team match-play brackets.
In 1955 tournament chairman, Herb Glenn, again elected to slightly modify the tournament format to a member guest style event with one Springhaven Member inviting a guest of another club. The two-man, 36-hole, better ball of partner medal format was won by Charles Albertus and Allan Sussel.